California · Workers' Compensation
What If My Workers' Comp Lawyer Withdraws From My Case in California?
The case keeps moving when your workers' comp lawyer withdraws, so treat every hearing date and deadline as firm. In an open WCAB case a lawyer cannot simply walk away: the judge must allow it unless you agree, and the lawyer must give you time to find help and release your file on request. You then hire a new lawyer or handle the case yourself, and any fee for the old lawyer still needs the judge's approval.
Eman Yazdchi, Esq., Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.
California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California

California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California
- 14+
- Years of Practice
- 2,000+
- Cases handled over 14+ years
- $50M+
- Recovered over 14+ years
- 3
- Languages: English, Español, Farsi
Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict future cases. Each case is different and results depend on specific facts and circumstances.
Prepared by Yazdchi Law
What happens if my workers' comp lawyer withdraws from my case?
Your lawyer stays on the case until the judge allows the withdrawal or you agree to a change, and then you hire someone new or act for yourself.
A withdrawal changes who represents you. It does not close the claim or stop the case. This page covers a case open before the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB). There, 8 CCR 10402(a) says attorneys are substituted or dismissed in the manner that Code of Civil Procedure sections 284, 285 and 286 provide.
Section 284 gives two ways to change a lawyer: client and lawyer both consent, with the consent filed or entered in the minutes, or the court orders the change on the application of the client or the lawyer, after notice from one to the other. The State Bar's rule 1.16(c) adds that a lawyer must not leave a case without the tribunal's permission when its rules require it.
If no case has been filed at the WCAB, there is no judge to ask for permission, but rule 1.16 still calls for notice, reasonable steps to avoid harm to you, and release of your file.
What makes a workers' comp lawyer withdraw from a case?
California's rule 1.16 lists the reasons, and it splits them into reasons that require a withdrawal and reasons that allow one.
These are the rule's categories in plain words. They do not describe any particular worker or firm.
A lawyer must withdraw when (rule 1.16(a)):
- the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that the client is pursuing a position without probable cause and to harass or maliciously injure someone;
- the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that the work would break the professional rules or the State Bar Act;
- the lawyer's health makes it unreasonably difficult to do the job; or
- the client discharges the lawyer.
A lawyer may withdraw when (rule 1.16(b)):
- the client insists on a claim that neither existing law nor a good-faith argument supports, seeks a crime or fraud, makes the work unreasonably difficult by other conduct, or breaks a material term of the agreement and does not fix it after a reasonable warning that the lawyer will withdraw;
- the client knowingly and freely agrees to end the representation;
- the lawyer cannot work with co-counsel and leaving would likely serve the client's interests, the lawyer's health makes the work difficult, or continuing would likely break the professional rules; or
- the lawyer believes in good faith that the tribunal will find other good cause.
Rule 1.16 does not say the lawyer must give you a reason. It does say a lawyer asking for permission must still protect your confidential information (comment 4), so the explanation may be short and general.
How does a withdrawal work at the WCAB?
The lawyer gives you notice, you either consent or the judge rules, and the other side is told in writing once the change is made.
- Notice to you. When the lawyer applies, section 284 calls for notice to you, and rule 1.16(d) says the lawyer may not leave until taking reasonable steps to avoid foreseeable harm to you, such as enough notice to find other counsel.
- Consent or an order. If you agree, the consent is filed or entered in the minutes. If not, the judge decides on the lawyer's application.
- A ruling. If the judge denies permission, the lawyer must follow the order (rule 1.16, comment 4).
- Notice to the other side. After the change, the other side must get written notice of the new lawyer or of your appearance in person. Until then it must keep dealing with the former lawyer (section 285).
- Papers to you. With no lawyer, service goes to you directly (8 CCR 10625(a)), and the WCAB serves you with any final order, decision or award it issues on a disputed issue after submission, whether or not you have a lawyer (8 CCR 10628(a)).
DWC publishes two forms for a worker who changes lawyers: Form 36, Substitution of Attorneys, and Form 37, Notice of Dismissal of Attorney. Our page on changing your workers' comp lawyer covers both.
What should I do right away?
Treat every date as firm, ask for your file in writing, and line up a new lawyer or a source of help before the next hearing.
| If this is your situation | What the rules say | Your step |
|---|---|---|
| A hearing or conference is already set | A judge grants a continuance only when good cause is clearly shown (8 CCR 10748). You or a lawyer or non-attorney representative must appear at hearings on your case (8 CCR 10752(a)). If a required party misses a settlement conference or trial after notice, the judge may take the case off calendar, continue it or issue a notice of intention (8 CCR 10755; 8 CCR 10756). | Keep the date. If you need time to find a new lawyer, ask the judge early and keep a copy of what you send. See our pages on continuances and required appearances. |
| Your old lawyer still has your file | On your request, a lawyer must promptly release client materials and property, whether or not you paid for them (rule 1.16(e)(1)). | Ask in writing and keep a copy of the request. |
| Papers start arriving at your address | Once you have no lawyer, the other side serves you directly (8 CCR 10625(a)). | Open everything, note the day it arrived, and make sure the district office and the claims administrator have your current address. |
| You hire a new lawyer | The new lawyer files a notice of representation (8 CCR 10400(a)) and completes a new fee disclosure form (Labor Code 4906(i)). | Bring the withdrawal papers, hearing notices, medical reports, benefit letters and your copy of the first fee disclosure form. |
| You go on alone for now | DWC says its Information and Assistance officers help you understand how to handle your own claim, and that they are not there to represent you (DWC FAQ). | Call 1-800-736-7401 or see our page on the Information and Assistance Unit. |
Keep the lawyer's notice, any consent or application, the judge's order, every hearing notice and your notes of each call. Our page on which records to keep lists the rest.
Do I owe my old lawyer anything?
A lawyer's fee in a workers' comp case needs the board's approval first, so a lawyer may not ask you for money before a judge sets an amount.
Labor Code section 4906(b) and 8 CCR 10840(a) say no attorney may request, demand or accept money from you for representing you before the WCAB until the fee has been approved or set by the board. The board may allow a reasonable attorney's fee as a lien against compensation (Labor Code 4903(a)). In setting it, a judge weighs the responsibility the lawyer assumed, the care exercised, the time involved and the results obtained (8 CCR 10844).
DWC's employee FAQ says an attorney cannot directly charge you and is paid out of a portion of your benefits. If you paid anything in advance that the lawyer has not earned or incurred, rule 1.16(e)(2) requires a prompt refund. How much a former lawyer may ask for, if anything, is for the judge. Our pages on fee approval and attorney fee liens explain the process.
How is a lawyer's withdrawal different from firing my lawyer?
When you end the relationship you file DWC's forms, and when the lawyer ends it the lawyer needs your consent or the judge's order.
The WCAB's rule on changing attorneys, 8 CCR 10402(a), points to the same code sections either way. DWC's guide 15 explains how a worker dismisses an attorney with Form 37 and says to send a copy to the attorney and to all the parties. If the lawyer has simply stopped answering and has not withdrawn, the State Bar describes an Attorney-Client Bridge Program for communication gaps.
Can another lawyer take over after a withdrawal?
Nothing in rule 1.16 or 8 CCR 10402 bars it, and each lawyer decides after reviewing the file.
A lawyer who takes over needs the papers listed above, especially anything with a date on it. Our page on when a workers' comp lawyer helps covers what a lawyer adds, and our page on handling a claim yourself covers the other path.
Results in cases like this
Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict a similar outcome.
$5,000,000
Catastrophic spinal cord injury
$1,500,000
Cervical spine injury
$425,000
Slip and fall accident
Find Out What Your Case May Be Worth
Two minutes. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.
Question 1 of 5
What type of injury do you have?
Not ready to fill this out? Just call (661) 273-1780 and we’ll ask the same questions by phone.
Free Consultation
Call or send the short form. We review your case, explain your rights, and outline your options. Free, no obligation.
We Build Your Case
We gather medical evidence, handle the insurance company, and file all the workers' comp court (WCAB) paperwork for you.
We Pursue Every Benefit
Medical care, lost wages, and permanent disability benefits. No fee unless we win your case; costs may apply.
If your lawyer has withdrawn, or has told you a request is coming, Yazdchi Law P.C. serves injured workers across California from its Palmdale office. The firm reviews each matter individually. Call (661) 273-1780 or use the contact form, and bring the withdrawal papers and every hearing notice. Fee requests are usually 15% to 18%, a workers' comp judge must approve them, and the fee guide explains the steps. The claim process guide maps the rest of the claim.
Injured at work? Talk it through for free.
Most claims must be filed within one year under Labor Code section 5405. A free call tells you where your clock stands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my case end when my lawyer withdraws?
No. A withdrawal changes who represents you, not whether the case goes on. The Code of Civil Procedure speaks of a party who appears in person after a change (section 285), and the WCAB rule on appearances lets you appear yourself or through a lawyer or representative (8 CCR 10752).
Can the judge refuse to let my lawyer withdraw?
Yes. Under section 284 the change happens on consent or on the court's order, and rule 1.16(c) bars a lawyer from leaving a case without the tribunal's permission when its rules require it. Comment 4 says a lawyer must follow the tribunal's order if permission is denied.
Will the papers say why my lawyer is leaving?
Not necessarily. Comment 4 to rule 1.16 says lawyers must still honor the duty to protect client confidences when they ask to withdraw, so the request may give only a short reason. You can ask your lawyer directly, and you can ask the new lawyer what the papers mean.
Do my deadlines pause while I look for a new lawyer?
Do not assume so. A petition for reconsideration, for example, is due 20 days after service of a final decision, with 5 more calendar days when the decision went to a California address by mail, fax or e-mail (Labor Code 5903; 8 CCR 10605), and the WCAB serves final decisions on you directly (8 CCR 10628(a)). If you need a hearing moved, ask the judge early, because continuances need a clear showing of good cause.
Is a "petition to be relieved as attorney" the same as a withdrawal?
People use that name for a lawyer's written request to leave a case. At the WCAB, the rule on changing attorneys is 8 CCR 10402(a), which points to Code of Civil Procedure 284 to 286. Section 284 lets the court order a change on the lawyer's application after notice to you.
What if my lawyer stops answering but has not withdrawn?
Until the other side gets written notice of a change, it must keep dealing with your lawyer (section 285), so the case is not on hold. You can ask the lawyer in writing for an update, use the State Bar's Attorney-Client Bridge Program, or dismiss the lawyer with DWC's Form 37.
Can I get my file if my lawyer withdraws?
Yes. On the termination of a representation for any reason, rule 1.16(e)(1) requires the lawyer to promptly release client materials and property at your request, whether or not you paid for them, subject to limits such as a protective order or a statute. If it is not released, the State Bar says it investigates allegations of attorney misconduct.
Free case evaluation
Get your free case evaluation
Three fields. We respond within one business day.
Talk to a Certified Specialist
Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.
Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.
Eman really knows his stuff and we were very pleased with our end result.
I am glad and so very pleased...he made happen what no other attorney could do. So far he has proven his weight in gold.
Client testimonials. Testimonials are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of your case.