Skip to main content

California · Workers' Compensation

What Is California Labor Code §3201.5: Construction Union Carve-Out Programs?

California Labor Code section 3201.5 lets qualifying construction employers and their union set up a special claims program. The program can use private mediation or arbitration, an agreed list of doctors and medical evaluators, and its own return to work track. It cannot take away your right to disability payments or employer paid medical care.

Eman Yazdchi, Esq., Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.

No Fee Unless We Win (Costs May Apply)Se Habla Español14+ Years
Eman Yazdchi, Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law (California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California)
Eman Yazdchi, Esq.Certified Specialist, Workers’ Compensation Law
California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California
14+
Years of Practice
2,000+
Cases handled over 14+ years
$50M+
Recovered over 14+ years
3
Languages: English, Español, Farsi

Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict future cases. Each case is different and results depend on specific facts and circumstances.

Prepared by Yazdchi Law

Nothing in this section shall allow a collective bargaining agreement that diminishes the entitlement of an employee to compensation payments for total or partial disability, temporary disability, vocational rehabilitation, or medical treatment fully paid by the employer as otherwise provided in this division. The portion of any agreement that violates this paragraph shall be declared null and void.

What is Labor Code 3201.5, in plain words?

It lets a qualifying construction employer and its union agree on their own claims process for covered workers, as long as the deal does not reduce your core benefits.

Most California workers' compensation claims follow one standard path. Section 3201.5 creates an exception for a specific slice of the construction industry. If your employer and your union have a qualifying collective bargaining agreement, it can set up its own dispute process, its own list of doctors, and its own list of medical evaluators. People in the field often call this kind of deal a union carve out, because it carves certain claims out of the usual process. The deal cannot do everything it wants. Subdivision (b) of the statute protects your core benefits no matter what the agreement says, and the rest of this page explains both sides.

This section only reaches a narrow group of employers. It covers a private employer, or a group of employers, in construction, construction maintenance, or work limited to rock, sand, gravel, cement, and asphalt operations, heavy duty mechanics, surveying, and construction inspection. The union side must be the workers' recognized or certified exclusive bargaining representative. Smaller employers in these trades are not included; the law also sets minimum insurance premium amounts, covered in the next section.

What can a qualifying 3201.5 program change about your claim?

It can change how disputes get decided, which doctors you see, and which evaluators review your medical disputes.

The statute lists six things a qualifying agreement can set up. First, an alternative dispute resolution system using mediation, arbitration, or both, in place of some of the usual steps. Second, an agreed list of medical treatment providers, which can be the only source of treatment the program allows. Third, an agreed, limited list of qualified medical evaluators (QMEs) and agreed medical evaluators (AMEs), the doctors who resolve disputed medical questions, which can be the only evaluators the program allows. Fourth, joint labor management safety committees. Fifth, a light duty, modified job, or return to work program. Sixth, a vocational rehabilitation or retraining program that uses its own agreed list of providers. Not every qualifying agreement uses all six; the union and employer choose which pieces to include.

Which employers and unions qualify to use this program?

Only larger construction employers, qualifying safety groups, self-insured employers, or large single-site wrap up policies meet the statute's size test.

The law sets a minimum size so the exception stays limited to bigger operations. The table below lists the four qualifying paths.

Type of employerWhat the statute requires
A single qualifying employerAn annual California workers' compensation insurance premium of $250,000 or more, developing, projected, or actually paid in at least one of the last three years
A group of employers in a safety groupAnnual premiums of $2,000,000 or more, organized under a joint labor management safety committee and meeting the Insurance Code's safety group rules
A self-insured employer or groupSelf-insured in compliance with Labor Code 3700, while meeting the same premium-based test
Employers on a single-site wrap up policyAn owner or general contractor wrap up insurance policy covering one construction site, with premiums of $2,000,000 or more for the employees it covers

Before any program can start, the administrative director reviews the paperwork and confirms the employer and union meet these rules. The employer must keep filing a copy of the agreement, proof of any required license, and a sworn statement that no court or agency has invalidated it. None of this paperwork changes what you are owed; it only confirms that a qualifying program is running.

What can this 3201.5 program never take away from you?

It cannot reduce your disability payments, vocational rehabilitation, or employer paid medical treatment, and any clause that tries is void.

Subdivision (b) is the protection quoted above. If an agreement tries to pay you less in disability benefits, or make you pay for medical treatment the employer should cover in full, that part of the agreement is null and void. The union and employer can still negotiate how medical and disability benefits are delivered for workers who also get group health coverage and nonoccupational disability benefits through the same employer, but that choice cannot leave you worse off than the statute otherwise requires.

How does arbitration work under this program, and what if you disagree with the result?

An arbitrator's decision counts the same as a judge's decision, and you can still ask the appeals board to review it.

If the program uses arbitration, the arbitrator's findings, award, order, or decision carry the same force and effect as one issued by a workers' compensation administrative law judge. You are not left without a check on that decision. The law sends review of an arbitration award through the same process used to review a judge's decision on reconsideration, starting at Labor Code section 5900, and on to the Court of Appeal under the rules starting at section 5950. That reconsideration process has its own strict filing deadline, so do not wait if you think the result is wrong. The statute also says this kind of arbitration is not subject to Labor Code Sections 5270, 5270.5, 5271, 5272, 5273, 5275, and 5277, so the usual rules under those specific sections do not apply to it.

How does Labor Code 3201.5 connect to other California rules, and what should you do next?

It sits next to the general rules on coverage, self-insurance, and appeals board review, and it has a close cousin for employers outside construction.

Section 3201.5 is one piece of the larger system described in Labor Code 3201, the foundation section that explains the state's authority to run a workers' compensation system at all. Labor Code 3201.7 sets up the same kind of program for qualifying employers outside the construction-related industries this section lists, through a separate labor management agreement instead of a term inside a collective bargaining agreement. For how mediation and arbitration fit into a claim generally, including for workers who are not covered by either of these programs, see our guide to mediation in a California workers' comp case. For the ordinary claim steps this kind of program can replace or add to, see the workers' comp claim process guide.

If you think your workplace has one of these agreements, ask your union representative or business agent to confirm it and to explain which pieces it uses. Keep any written notice about the program, your claim form, and any letter naming the doctors or evaluators you must use. If you believe an agreement is being used to pay you less than the law allows, that part of the deal is void, and you do not have to accept it without asking questions first.

Results in cases like this

Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict a similar outcome.

$415,000

Motor vehicle accident

$5,000,000

Catastrophic spinal cord injury

$1,500,000

Cervical spine injury

Find Out What Your Case May Be Worth

Two minutes. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.

Question 1 of 5

What type of injury do you have?

Not ready to fill this out? Just call (661) 273-1780 and we’ll ask the same questions by phone.

01

Free Consultation

Call or send the short form. We review your case, explain your rights, and outline your options. Free, no obligation.

02

We Build Your Case

We gather medical evidence, handle the insurance company, and file all the workers' comp court (WCAB) paperwork for you.

03

We Pursue Every Benefit

Medical care, lost wages, and permanent disability benefits. No fee unless we win your case; costs may apply.

If you are a construction worker and you think your employer and union have a Labor Code 3201.5 agreement, or you are unsure how your claim is being handled under one, Yazdchi Law P.C. reviews each case individually. Call (661) 273-1780 or use the contact form to talk through your situation.

Injured at work? Talk it through for free.

Most claims must be filed within one year under Labor Code section 5405. A free call tells you where your clock stands.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Labor Code 3201.5 apply to every construction worker in California?

No. It only reaches workers whose employer, or group of employers, works in construction, construction maintenance, or the specific trades the statute lists, and whose insurance premiums or self-insured costs meet the minimum size test. Most construction workers in California are not covered by one of these agreements.

Can my employer use a Labor Code 3201.5 agreement to pay me less in disability benefits?

No. The statute says any part of the agreement that reduces your disability payments, vocational rehabilitation, or employer paid medical treatment is null and void. The employer and union can change the process around your claim, but not cut what you are owed.

Who chooses the doctor if my workplace has one of these agreements?

The program can make an agreed list of providers the only source of treatment it allows, instead of the choices you would otherwise have. Ask your union representative which list applies to you and how to see a provider on it.

What happens if I disagree with an arbitrator's decision under this program?

An arbitration award under this program has the same force as a workers' compensation judge's decision, and the appeals board reviews it the same way it reviews a petition for reconsideration. That review has a strict deadline, so act quickly if you want to challenge the result.

Is a 3201.5 program the same thing as the mediation available to other workers?

No. Most California workers can ask for a voluntary mediation conference if they do not have an attorney, which is a different, narrower process. This kind of program is a separate, negotiated system that only exists where a qualifying construction employer and union set one up.

Can this program include a return to work or retraining plan?

Yes. The statute allows a light duty, modified job, or return to work program, and a separate vocational retraining program that uses its own agreed list of providers. Whether your workplace actually uses either piece depends on what the employer and union agreed to.

How do I find out if my union has a Labor Code 3201.5 agreement?

Ask your union representative or business agent first; they should know whether the union has negotiated one of these programs and which parts it uses. You can also ask your employer or claims administrator for any written notice describing the program.

Free case evaluation

Get your free case evaluation

Three fields. We respond within one business day.

Talk to a Certified Specialist

Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.

Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We keep what you send confidential within our office and the services that help us reply to you.

Eman at Yazdchi Law was extremely professional, responsive, and supportive at all times. He and his staff exceeded all of my expectations.
Andrea Dalessandro
A fighting force both consistent and compassionate on a scale’s a 5 all around.
Rachael Hall

Client testimonials. Testimonials are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of your case.