Skip to main content

California · Workers' Compensation

Can You Sue a Workers' Comp Insurance Company or Adjuster in California?

Usually not. In California, a dispute with a workers' comp insurer over a denied claim or late checks goes to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB), and a refused treatment request goes through a state medical review process, not to a civil court. For an unreasonably delayed payment, the WCAB can add a penalty of up to 25 percent of that payment, with a $10,000 ceiling, and the Labor Code says that penalty does not create a lawsuit. Other people can be sued in a few situations, so check with a lawyer before you file anything.

Eman Yazdchi, Esq., Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.

No Fee Unless We Win (Costs May Apply)Se Habla Español14+ Years
Eman Yazdchi, Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law (California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California)
Eman Yazdchi, Esq.Certified Specialist, Workers’ Compensation Law
California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California
14+
Years of Practice
2,000+
Cases handled over 14+ years
$50M+
Recovered over 14+ years
3
Languages: English, Español, Farsi

Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict future cases. Each case is different and results depend on specific facts and circumstances.

Prepared by Yazdchi Law

Can you sue a workers' comp insurance company in California?

Usually not. A denied claim or a late check goes before the WCAB, and a refused treatment request goes through the insurer's utilization review and then state-run independent medical review, so none of them starts as a lawsuit.

The source of this rule is Labor Code section 5300. It says that proceedings to recover compensation, and to enforce a liability for compensation against "the employer or an insurer," are brought before the appeals board "and not elsewhere," unless Division 4 of the code (the workers' comp part) says otherwise.

People who ask this often have one of four problems: a denied claim, late checks, refused treatment or an adjuster who will not act. The state Division of Workers' Compensation (DWC) describes its offices as trial courts where a judge, without a jury, decides workers' comp disputes (DWC page on a denied claim). The table shows where each problem goes.

The problemWhere it goes instead of a lawsuitRule
The claim was deniedFile an Application for Adjudication of Claim with the WCAB, then ask for a hearing before a judge.Labor Code 5300(a); DWC denied-claim page
Checks are lateAn automatic 10 percent increase on the late payment unless an exception applies, and a penalty request to the WCAB if the delay was unreasonable.Labor Code 4650(d); 5814(a)
Treatment was refused or delayedUtilization review, then Independent Medical Review. A penalty request is possible for an unreasonable delay.Labor Code 4610.5(b); 5814(a)
An adjuster stalls or does not act fairlyA complaint to the DWC Audit Unit. State rules call for a reasonable investigation and fair dealing.8 CCR 10109
The other side uses frivolous or delay-only tactics in your WCAB caseA sanctions request to the WCAB for costs, attorney's fees and up to $2,500 for the state.Labor Code 5813
An insurer knowingly or routinely breaks the Insurance Code's claim rulesThe Insurance Commissioner can investigate and fine the insurer. The fine goes to the state.Insurance Code 790.03(h); 790.035

This guide covers the insurer that pays your workers' comp claim. Your own health plan or a private disability policy is separate coverage with different rules.

Why does California send these disputes to the WCAB?

Workers' comp replaces a fault-based lawsuit with no-fault benefits, and the Labor Code places the fight over those benefits in the WCAB.

Under section 3600(a), an employer owes compensation without regard to negligence, and that duty replaces any other liability to anyone, except in the cases named in sections 3602, 3706 and 4558. Section 3602(a) adds that compensation is the employee's sole and exclusive remedy against the employer, apart from the listed exceptions. An insurer pays that compensation for the employer.

Nothing in sections 5300 or 5814 gives a worker a lawsuit against the insurer over benefits. Section 5955 goes further: no California court, apart from the appellate courts as the code allows, has jurisdiction to review, reverse, correct or annul a WCAB decision. The penalty section ends with this sentence:

Nothing in this section shall be construed to create a civil cause of action.

Can you sue a workers' comp insurer for bad faith or delay?

Not under the Labor Code's penalty rules. The WCAB can add money to a delayed payment, and the code says that is not a lawsuit.

When payment of compensation is unreasonably delayed or refused, section 5814(a) raises the payment by up to 25 percent of the late amount, with a $10,000 ceiling on the increase. How much to add is left to the board's discretion. A separate rule adds 10 percent to any indemnity payment that is not made on time, without a request and with listed exceptions (section 4650(d)). Section 5814(d) subtracts the 10 percent already paid from the larger penalty. Our Labor Code 5814 guide and our page on insurer delay and bad faith cover the penalty in detail.

The state's good-faith rule is a regulation, not a lawsuit. Under 8 CCR 10109, a claims administrator has to investigate each claim in a reasonable and timely way, and may not limit that work to building a defense. Insurers, self-insured employers and third-party administrators must also deal fairly and in good faith with all claimants. The regulation is part of DWC's auditing rules, and the Audit Unit is the unit that takes complaints about claims administrators.

Bad tactics inside your WCAB case fall under section 5813. The WCAB may order a party, its attorney or both to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees and costs, caused by frivolous or delay-only bad-faith tactics, plus sanctions of up to $2,500 for the General Fund. A party can ask in writing, or the board can act on its own.

What can you do about an unfair insurer or a bad adjuster?

Report it to the state. DWC takes complaints about how a claims administrator delivers benefits, and the Insurance Commissioner enforces the Insurance Code's claim rules.

DWC says its Audit Unit tracks complaints against all workers' comp claims administrators and takes steps to see that benefit laws are obeyed. It does not settle benefit disputes. Those go to the WCAB or DWC's Claims Adjudication Unit (DWC filing a complaint page). Our guide to complaining about a workers' comp adjuster walks through the form.

The Insurance Code lists unfair claims settlement practices, such as failing to act reasonably promptly on communications about claims or failing to explain a denial promptly and reasonably (section 790.03(h)). The list reaches only practices committed knowingly, or "with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice." The Commissioner may investigate (section 790.04) and can fine an insurer up to $5,000 for each act, or up to $10,000 if the act was willful. The fine is owed to the state, not to you (section 790.035).

When can you sue someone in a work injury case?

You can sue some people other than the insurer: a third party whose fault caused your injury, and an employer or coworker only in the cases the Labor Code lists.

WhoWhat the Labor Code saysRelated guide
A person or company that is not your employer or its insurerFiling for compensation leaves intact your separate claim for damages against anyone except the employer (section 3852(a)). In that chapter of the code, "employer" includes the insurer (section 3850(b)), so the right does not reach the insurer.Third-party injury claims
An employer with no workers' comp coverageAn employee of an employer that failed to secure compensation may bring an action at law for damages, as if Division 4 did not apply (section 3706).Uninsured employers
An employer, in three listed casesAn employer whose willful physical assault caused your injury, whose fraudulent concealment of an injury and its job connection made it worse, or that made a defective product that injured you after it was sold, leased or otherwise transferred to an independent third person for value and then provided for your use by a third person (section 3602(b)).Exclusive remedy exceptions
A coworker, in two listed casesWillful and unprovoked physical aggression, or intoxication (section 3601(a)).Suing a coworker

No row lets you sue the insurer over benefits. Whether any other civil claim could exist against an insurer or an adjuster depends on facts and on court decisions beyond the statutes cited here. A California attorney should review your facts before you file a lawsuit anywhere.

What deadlines apply on the WCAB route?

A penalty request has a two-year limit, and a decision you disagree with must be challenged within days, not months.

StepClockRule
Ask for a penalty on an unreasonably delayed paymentTwo years counted from the day the payment fell dueLabor Code 5814(g)
Petition the WCAB to reconsider a final order, decision or award20 days after service, plus 5 calendar days if the paper came by fax, e-mail or mail and the address is in CaliforniaLabor Code 5903; 8 CCR 10605(a)(1)
Ask an appellate court to review the WCAB's decision45 days after reconsideration is denied, or after the decision that follows reconsiderationLabor Code 5950

These clocks run from dates on your papers, so keep the envelope or e-mail that shows when each notice arrived. A civil lawsuit, where one is allowed, follows its own court deadlines, so ask a lawyer about timing before you file.

What should you do and keep before you decide?

Build a dated paper trail now, because every WCAB remedy and every state complaint turns on dates and notices.

  1. Keep every denial, delay notice, letter and check stub, with the date each one arrived.
  2. List each late payment with its due date, its paid date and the amount. Penalties are measured payment by payment.
  3. Write to the adjuster, name the benefit and the date, and keep proof that you sent it.
  4. For a denied claim, file the Application for Adjudication. DWC says you may represent yourself or hire an attorney.
  5. For a complaint about handling, use DWC's audit referral form from its filing a complaint page.
  6. Talk to a California attorney before you file any civil lawsuit. Our denied claim guide and our page on denied treatment cover the usual next steps.

Results in cases like this

Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict a similar outcome.

$5,000,000

Catastrophic spinal cord injury

$1,500,000

Cervical spine injury

$425,000

Slip and fall accident

Find Out What Your Case May Be Worth

Two minutes. No fee unless we win; costs may apply.

Question 1 of 5

What type of injury do you have?

Not ready to fill this out? Just call (661) 273-1780 and we’ll ask the same questions by phone.

01

Free Consultation

Call or send the short form. We review your case, explain your rights, and outline your options. Free, no obligation.

02

We Build Your Case

We gather medical evidence, handle the insurance company, and file all the workers' comp court (WCAB) paperwork for you.

03

We Pursue Every Benefit

Medical care, lost wages, and permanent disability benefits. No fee unless we win your case; costs may apply.

When does a lawyer help if the insurer is the problem?

A lawyer helps most when a denial, a run of late payments or a refused treatment request is past what a letter can fix. The firm can compare your notices with the deadlines, ask the WCAB for penalties or sanctions, handle the hearing, and tell you whether anyone else could be sued. Yazdchi Law P.C., based in Palmdale, represents injured workers across California and reviews each matter individually. No attorney may take a fee until a workers' comp judge signs off on it, a rule found in Labor Code section 4906. Fee requests usually run 15% to 18%. Our attorney fee guide has the details. To go over your papers, call (661) 273-1780 or use the contact form.

Injured at work? Talk it through for free.

Most claims must be filed within one year under Labor Code section 5405. A free call tells you where your clock stands.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my workers' comp adjuster personally?

Usually not over your benefits. Section 5300 sends benefit disputes to the WCAB, and the remedies are penalties, sanctions and state complaints. For an adjuster's handling, use the DWC Audit Unit. The Department of Insurance says its Investigation Division looks into suspected fraud against consumers by insurance companies and others who transact the business of insurance (Department of Insurance complaint page). A lawyer can tell you whether your facts raise anything more.

Can I sue my employer for denying my workers' comp claim?

Not over the denial itself. The claims administrator decides whether to accept or deny a claim, and that can be an insurance company, the employer itself when it is self-insured, or an outside administrator hired to run claims. A denial is challenged at the WCAB. Section 3602(a) makes workers' comp the exclusive remedy against the employer outside the listed cases, and a denial is not one of them. If your employer punished you for filing, a separate petition under section 132a is filed with the appeals board, and it has a one-year limit. See our Labor Code 132a retaliation guide.

Can I still sue after a workers' comp settlement?

Usually not against the insurer over benefits. Approval of a compromise and release, findings and awards, or stipulations and orders is conclusively presumed to resolve accrued penalty claims, unless the order specifically leaves them out (section 5814(c)). A claim against a third party is separate (section 3852(a)). The appeals board keeps continuing jurisdiction over its orders and may change one when good cause is shown (section 5803), but section 5804 limits changes to an award to five years from the injury date, unless a petition was filed within those five years.

Is it worth asking the WCAB for a penalty?

That depends on the dollars and the dates. The penalty reaches only the payment that was unreasonably delayed or refused, it has a ceiling, and the 10 percent already paid on that payment comes off it. Whether a delay was unreasonable is for the board to decide on the facts. Section 5814(e) adds that no unreasonable delay is found when treatment was authorized on time and the only dispute is a provider's bill. Have a lawyer look at your dates first.

Can I sue over a denied treatment request?

A dispute over a utilization review decision "shall be resolved only in accordance with" the Independent Medical Review rules (section 4610.5(b)). The worker's request is generally due within 30 days after the review decision is served, or within 10 days in a dispute over a formulary drug (section 4610.5(h)). Our guide to denied treatment explains the steps.

Free case evaluation

Get your free case evaluation

Three fields. We respond within one business day.

Talk to a Certified Specialist

Certified Specialist in Workers' Compensation Law, California Board of Legal Specialization, State Bar of California.

Takes 30 seconds. No obligation.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We keep what you send confidential within our office and the services that help us reply to you.

A fighting force both consistent and compassionate on a scale’s a 5 all around.
Rachael Hall
Very thankful for everything they did for us. Always responsive, reassured us every step of the way and obtained a great result.
Miguel Orellana

Client testimonials. Testimonials are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of your case.